Susan Neiling

February 3, 1958 – April 4, 2026

Susan Neiling, 68, Arcadia, passed away on April 4, 2026, at St. Vincent Hospital in Indianapolis.

She was born on February 3, 1958 in Lima, Ohio, to Dick and Jackie Versprille.

Sue graduated from Patrick Henry High School in 1976. She married the love of her life, Tony Neiling, in 1974 and they spent 33 years together loving each other and raising their family. Sue loved caring for children and spent most of her career running an in-home daycare. She also ran a successful cookie-and-balloon business for several years, and many people have fond memories of receiving her bouquets. Sue was an avid game player; she loved playing Bingo, Yahtzee, Skip-Bo, Rummy, or any other card game you’d want to sit down and play with her. But if you asked her, her favorite thing was spending time with her grandchildren.

Sue will be remembered for her giving heart, always one of the first to offer support or a meal when someone was going through a hard time. She was very connected to her community; she always remembered someone’s birthday, anniversary, or a significant event in their life. With faith being an important part of her life, she attended Arcadia Church of the Brethren. She knew that when her time was done in this world, she’d get to meet her Savior and dance in the streets with her husband.

She is survived by her mother-in-law, Donna Neiling; her children, Tony (Amie) Neiling and Heather Trump; her siblings, Rich (Karen) Versprille, Rob (Deanna) Versprille, and Tammy (Andy) Miller; grandchildren, Belle, Theo, and Eli Neiling, and Aerial and Aleha Trump; her great-granddaughter, Leilani Trump; and many nieces and nephews. She was preceded in death by her husband, Tony Neiling; her parents, Dick Versprille and Jackie Versprille; and her father-in-law, Raymond Neiling.

Sue did not want people to be sad about her passing because she knew she was going Home, so she opted not to have a funeral service. However, there will be a private family graveside service in the future. The family would also like to thank all of Sue’s caregivers, medical professionals and volunteers that contributed to her long-term care throughout her journey.

Sue will be deeply missed and forever remembered by all those who knew and loved her.

Condolences: hartleyfuneralhome.com