Shaffer: Carmel’s budget numbers just don’t add up

Letters to the Editor do not reflect the opinions of The Reporter, its publisher or its staff. You can submit your own Letter to the Editor by email to News@ReadTheReporter.com.


Dear Editor:

Carmel’s municipal establishment can no longer hide its feeble deception where budget and spending are concerned.

Using the city’s own data – as reported to the Indiana Department of Local Government Finance (IDLGF) and published reports in the press – we learn:

  • The mayor’s budget since 2014 has declined 22 percent;
  • Spending per resident actually declined 26 percent as population grew 16 percent;
  • Official city budgets filed with the IDLGF for 2016 (the most recent filing) showed the city budget to be $83.7 million, not the $125 million the mayor claimed in print;
  • Property tax revenues since 2014 increased 45 percent;
  • The city’s actual deficit in 2014 was $10.8 million and in 2020, $42.5 million.

And yet, the city propeller heads have approved another $150 million or so in new borrowing (plus interest) to add to the $1.3 billion burden it’s already run up by exploiting loopholes in state law.

If Carmel were a publicly traded corporation, the Securities and Exchange Commission would shut it down.

Bill Shaffer

Carmel