Shaffer calls for township independence

Letters to the Editor do not reflect the opinions of The Reporter, its publisher or its staff. You can submit your own Letter to the Editor by email to News@ReadTheReporter.com.


Dear Editor:

Carmel City Hall elites have dashed all hopes non-mayors had for a return to fiscal responsibility in local government.

As reported in this newspaper, councilors unveiled a $59.8 million plan for Clay Township to finance city fire department, parks department and roundabout construction costs.

Hiding behind a grand plan for a Dads’ Club facility were projects the city otherwise would have to borrow money and further erode its own credit standing.

This the city cannot do. It’s tapped out. Carmel’s year-end debt load was $213.9 million; the Redevelopment Commission, $572.7 million, for a city-wide $786.6 million.

Historically, Clay Township has carried at $33 to $47 million debt load, according to the Indiana Department of Local Government Finance. Now, Clay Township will run its debt from $29 million to $89 million for City Hall benefit.

Granted, Clay Township is all within city limits, but legally is a separate governmental entity over which the city council has no formal control.

Forget that. The highly in-bred municipal machine steamrollered any thoughts of township independence much as the machine politicians have done in Chicago and Cook County, Ill., for years.

Bill Shaffer

Carmel